Home Boys' Lists Girls' Lists Men's Teams Women's Teams News Photos Contributors Links Help Sign-UpOnline Store
Latest News | Categories | Authors | News Archives
 
 

News & Features

College Opinion
Matching Up: A New Way to Think About College Tennis Lineups
Share:    

I have been a sports fan ever since I can remember, and a tennis fan since my teens, but my interest in college tennis is much more recent.

College tennis coaches submit their lineups for review
© ZooTennis.com
I mention that personal history to explain why I have never shared the outrage directed at a coach who is accused of stacking a lineup (inserting an inferior player at a higher position in the expectation of getting additional wins with stronger players pushed lower in the lineup). That concern just never made sense in the context of the sports I grew up with. The rule that players be slotted into playing positions via a judgment of their games' strengths is so foreign to most sports that it's difficult to find another example of it. One of the truisms of sport is that it's all about matchups, and yet that concept is expressly prohibited in college tennis.

Can you imagine an NBA coach forced to determine his best player, then required to send that player to defend the opposing team's best player? Or a major league baseball rule that demands a manager rank his relief pitchers by ability then compels him to use his team's second-best relief pitcher against the opponent's second-best hitter late in the game?

Managing matchups is what coaches and managers do, and college tennis coaches are certainly capable of taking on that responsibility. Right now, considerable time is devoted to lineup challenges and protest hearings, time better spent coaching, marketing, and connecting with the university and its community. Below is my proposal for a radical change in how lineups are set in college tennis:

An hour or so before the dual match, both coaches meet with the referee. They submit a list of their players available for the match. The list doesn't have to be in any particular order and could contain six or more players. After a 15-minute window for the coaches to review the opponent's list, the referee tosses a coin, with the host school coach declaring heads or tails.

The coach who wins the toss may declare her player for match #1 or defer, so that the other coach must first make her designation of their player for match #1. After the first player for match # 1 is designated, the other coach names her player for match #1 and then declares her choice of player for match #2. The other coach then responds with her player for match #2 and designates a player for match #3 and so on until all six singles matches have players designated.

Setting lineups could be done much differently
© ZooTennis.com
Then, the process is repeated for doubles teams, with the coach who lost the initial coin toss given the choice to first name a doubles team for match #1 or require the other coach declare first.

All players selected must come from the submitted list of players available. Once the line-up is created, no substitutions are allowed. To eliminate possible gamesmanship, a player suddenly stricken by "match flu" or even a legitimate last-minute injury would result in a walkover.

    Example:
Host coach chooses heads. The coin toss shows tails. The visiting coach chooses to defer the first declaration. The host coach then designates the second player on his list to play in match #1. The visiting coach designates player the third player from his list to be the opponent in match #1 and declares that the first player on his list will play in match #2. Next, the home coach designates the third player from his list to be the opponent in match #2 and that the seventh player from his list will play in match #3 and so on until all six matches are filled. Then, for doubles, the home coach decides to declare first and names player #1 & 5 to be in dubs match #1. The visiting coach chooses players #2 and 3 to be the opponent for dubs match #1 and designates players #7 and 1 for dubs match #2 and so on.

The benefits:

  • Eliminates the ranking of players on a team and does not require that the "best" player on team A play the "best" player on team B.

  • Eliminates lineup challenges and protests, removing friction between coaches over such issues

  • Allows coaches to give their players experience against perceived stronger or weaker players, which could enhance their development.

  • Allows coaches to give an opportunity to a player who needs a ranked win to make the NCAAs

  • Allows newcomers to adjust to college tennis without being pigeon-holed in a position from their first match.

  • Provides an opportunity to work a player into a lineup after an injury

  • Provides a more democratic atmosphere on the team, perhaps eliminating internal squabbles over who is highest on the totem pole.

As a fan, I believe this process would deliver more intrigue and fun, with more options for armchair quarterbacking, than the current system, which frowns on change from match to match. It's true that some coaches currently do adjust their lineups with an eye toward enhancing their chance to win the match. Rather than trying to legislate against that, why not experiment to see who has the skill to excel in that facet of coaching?
 
 

About Diadem

College Content at TennisRecruiting.net is sponsored by Diadem.

Diadem was founded in 2015 with a single goal in mind - develop the most innovative, high-quality tennis products in the world to help players maximize their performance. We found that the tennis industry had become stagnant, with very few brands that were challenging the status quo. With a team made up of former collegiate and professional players and coaches, Diadem set out to develop new and exciting products that catered to players of all levels looking to elevate their game.

Diadem is committed to supporting the growth of junior tennis in America and across the globe. Our Dynasty Team sponsorship program is unlike any junior tennis sponsorship program in the world. Beyond providing high quality equipment at a great price point for junior players we are continuously innovating to improve our players experience with the sport and to help them accomplish their goals. We give our athletes the "pro player treatment," to equip them with racket setups that are tailored to their game. We leverage our relationship with hundreds of college coaches across the country to help our players take their game to the next level. We're continuously evolving to better support our sponsored players from coast to coast!

Connect with Diadem on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok and - or on their website.

 

Leave a Comment

 

More College Coverage

6-Mar-2024
ITA National Indoor Championships
The ITA National Indoor Championships have concluded for the year with winners in all three NCAA divisions and the NAIA level. From repeat titles to historic breakthroughs, read all the stories about how the champions were crowned.

21-Feb-2024
Ohio State Captures Indoor Title with Thrilling Win over TCU
Ohio State claimed its third ITA Division I National Men's Indoor Team title on Monday in New York with a thrilling 4-3 comeback victory over Texas Christian University to deny the Horned Frogs a third-straight title. Fifth-year senior Robert Cash clinched the victory with a three-set singles win.

13-Feb-2024
Oklahoma State Captures First ITA National Indoor Title
The Oklahoma State women captured the program's first ITA National Indoor title with a thrilling 4-3 victory over Michigan on Monday in Seattle. The Cowgirls notched their fourth top-six win by fighting off a Michigan comeback attempt.

 
 College Coverage Index |   Subscribe

 

         
About Colette Lewis

Colette Lewis has covered topflight U.S. and international junior events as a freelance journalist for over a decade. Her work has appeared in Tennis magazine, the Tennis Championships magazine and the US Open program. Lewis is active on Twitter, and she writes a weekly column right here at TennisRecruiting.net. She was named Junior Tennis Champion for 2016 by Tennis Industry Magazine.

Lewis, based out of Kalamazoo, Michigan, has seen every National Championship final played since 1977, and her work on the tournament's ustaboys.com website led her to establish ZooTennis, where she comments on junior and college tennis daily.

 
 DIADEM
 
Nova V3 | Explosive Power
 
In the fast-paced world of tennis, where precision and power are paramount, Diadem Sports proudly introduces the Nova V3 series, a groundbreaking fusion of cutting-edge technology and unparalleled performance.
 
RECENT COMMITMENTS
 
RECENT HEADLINES
ITA NEWS
THE LATEST FROM ZOOTENNIS
3/27 Last Alternate Burnett Ousts Defending Champion Chinlund in Easter Bowl 18s Second Round; Mixed Fortunes for Previous Easter Bowl Champions With…
3/26 Unseeded Bracks Beats No. 1 Gelletich Again, Ayrault and Bronson Foster Avenge Losses in Ousting Top Seeds in 14s and 12s at FILA Easter Bowl; Jose…
3/25 Amey Ousts No. 3 Seed in Second Round B14s Easter Bowl Action, 18s and 16s Begin Play Monday; SMU's Svajda Claims First Pro Circuit Title; Texas…
3/24 Jovic and Kennedy Claim ITF J300 Titles in San Diego; Teens Basavareddy and Svajda Reach Calabasas $25K Final; Easter Bowl Underway at Indian Wells
3/23 Indian Wells ITF J300 Recap; Mayew Versus Kennedy in Boys ITF J300 San Diego Final, Jovic and Penickova Reach Girls Championship Match; Stanford…
Colette Lewis has covered topflight junior events as a freelance journalist for over a decade. Read her weekly column, follow her on Twitter, and and find more of her daily commentary at ZooTennis.
 
TALK TENNIS
 

Page updated on Monday, March 11, 2024
Contact our web team with any corrections